A clash over the future of the former Central United Church is heading to city council as heritage advocates push for protection while owners warn of financial ruin.
The Sarnia Heritage Committee is asking city council to designate the former Central United Church at 220 George Street under the Ontario Heritage Act, citing its architectural significance. However, the property’s current owners warn that such a move will scuttle a pending sale and could make the site impossible to develop.
Built in 1883, the structure is described by the committee as a rare Canadian example of the Queen Anne architectural style. The committee argues the building is a landmark that defines the character of the neighbourhood and requires protection to prevent demolition by neglect.
Representatives for the owner, Xoana Corporation, have submitted a strong objection to the designation. They state that they have an accepted offer on the property, but the buyers will walk away if the designation proceeds.
Monteith Brown Planning Consultants, representing the prospective buyer Heikal Group Inc., has requested council defer the decision. The group is planning a high-density residential development on the site that would retain the church building but argues that immediate designation would constrain the development of the surrounding lands.
In correspondence with city staff, Xoana Corporation described the potential designation as a "death sentence" for their small company. They noted that previous financing was rejected once lenders saw the property was listed on the heritage register.
City staff are recommending council proceed with the notice of intention to designate the property. Under Bill 23, properties listed on the municipal heritage register must be designated by January 1, 2027, or they will be removed from the list and left unprotected.
